Last Updated on 10 October 2026

The following list is a compilation of the 25 best portrayals of Captain Hook of all time.

I found 30 different ranked lists online of “best Captain Hook actors of all time” and pulled them all into Excel and merged them all to get this definitive compilation. See my Methodology page for the research process that was used, including links to all 30 lists that were averaged. Below is a ranked list with links to IMDb.

  1. Dustin Hoffman - Hook (1991)
  2. Jason Isaacs - Peter Pan (2003)
  3. Hans Conried - Peter Pan (1953)
  4. Colin O'Donoghue - Once Upon a Time (2012-2018)
  5. Cyril Ritchard - Peter Pan (1960)
  6. Tim Curry - Peter Pan and the Pirates (1990-1991)
  7. Rhys Ifans - Neverland (2011)
  8. Garrett Hedlund - Pan (2015)
  9. Tom Hiddleston - The Pirate Fairy (2014)
  10. Christopher Walken - Peter Pan: Live! (2014)
  11. Ernest Torrence - Peter Pan (1924)
  12. Stanley Tucci - Peter and Wendy (2015)
  13. Corey Burton - Return to Never Land (2002)
  14. Jude Law - Peter Pan & Wendy (2023)
  15. Ian McShane - Shrek the Third (2007)
  16. Danny Kaye - Peter Pan (1976)
  17. Kevin Pugh - Wendy (2020)
  18. Christian Borle - Peter and the Starcatcher play (2009)
  19. David Gyasi - Come Away (2020)
  20. Paul Schoeffler - Peter Pan Broadway (1999)
  21. Henry Shields - Peter Pan Goes Wrong (2016)
  22. Kelsey Grammer - Finding Neverland: The Musical (2015)
  23. J.K. Simmons - Peter Pan Broadway (1991)
  24. Anthony Warlow - Finding Neverland: The Musical (2015)
  25. Anthony Head - The Children’s Party at the Palace (2006)

    Honorable mention:
  26. Boris Karloff - Peter Pan musical (1950)

Loading